The U.S. X-Plane Program has evolved from being the first rocket-powered
airplane to break the sound barrier (the X-1 on OctoberÃ14, 1947) and included
over 30 different major research designs, although not all were developed
into flying prototypes (Hallion 1984, Miller 1988, DFRC/EAFB 1994-A/B,
and DFRC/EAFB 1995). As the program progressed, other non-rocket-powered
experimental aircraft were built and tested. These aircraft included: a
range of vertical takeoff and horizontal landing vehicles; smaller, propeller-driven
reconnaissance vehicles; and a series of unmanned missile testbeds of both
single and multistage designs. Although the program grew to include conventional
propeller-driven aircraft, all designs had in common the aspect of being
highly valuable research tools for advancement of aerodynamics and astronautics.
Accomplishments of the X-Plane family have been many. The program included:
(1) the first aircraft to break the sound barrier; (2) the first aircraft
to use a variable-sweep-wing in flight; (3) the first to fly at altitudes
in excess of 30,000, 60,000, and 90,000 m (100,000, 200,000 and 300,000Ãft);
(4) the first to use exotic alloy metals for primary structure; (5) the
first to test gimbaled jet and rocket engines; (6) the first to use jet-thrust
for launch and landing; (7)Ãthe first to fly three, four, five, and six
times the speed of sound; (8) the first to test boundary-layer-airflow
control theories over an entire wing at transonic speeds; (9) the first
to successfully complete a 180Ãdegree turn using a post-stall maneuver;
and (10) the first missile to reach an intercontinental flight range.
The majority of testing for the X-Plane family has occurred at Edwards
Air Force Base (formerly known as Muroc Army Airfield). Hosts within Edwards
include the Air Force Flight Test Center and Dryden Flight Research Center.
Other sites which have served as X-Plane testing sites include: Langley
Research Center and Ames Research Center; various Government owned ships;
White Sands Missile Range, New Mexico; Wright-Patterson Air Force Base,
Ohio; Cape Canaveral Air Station, Florida; Pinecastle Air Force Base, Florida;
Buffalo, New York; and the National Aviation Facilities Experimental Center
in Atlantic City, New Jersey. Edwards has seen more X-Plane programs and
test flights than any other similar facility in the U.S.
As with every research program testing prototype equipment, the X-Plane
Program has not been without technical glitches and equipment failures.
Since the beginning of the programís manned flight operations in
1946, approximately 15 major accidents and 4 fatalities (pilots) have been
associated with manned vehicle tests. Three of these fatalities were from
the X-2 Program, flown between 1952 and 1956, and the remaining fatality
happened in 1967 during an X-15 research flight. Stringent range safety
controls have resulted in no civilian property damage losses or fatalities
being reported as a result of any X-Plane Program accident. Given the overwhelming
number of test flights, the small number of accidents which resulted in
loss of aircraft or life can be considered a remarkable program achievement.
Table A-1 provides key information about each plane tested in the X-Plane
series of vehicles.
Another member of the X-Plane Program would be the X-33. As a reusable
spaceplane, the X-33 continues the research line developed by various components
of the X-Program, such as the X-10 which tested cruise missile components;
the X-12, the Atlas B missile which tested one-and-one-half propulsion
staging and obtained the first intercontinental flight distance for a U.S.
missile; the X-15 which explored the problems of space and reentry at high
speeds (Mach 6) and altitudes; the X-17 which explored high Mach effects
on reentry vehicles; and the X-23A which was the first maneuvering lifting
reentry vehicle. The X-17 was a multistage rocket design which transported
various reentry vehicle configurations to very high altitudes to examine
their reentry characteristics. The X-23A was launched by a modified intercontinental
ballistic missile and utilized a ìlifting bodyî design to
glide back to earth. Information acquired from the X-23A was instrumental
in later development of the Space Shuttle.
Table A-1. Summary of the X-Plane Program.
|
Model
|
Manufacturer
|
No. of Vehicles Built
|
Years of Operation
|
No. of Flights
|
Primary Testing Facility
|
Research Goals
|
Program Achievements
|
No. of
Major Accidents
|
Causes of Accidents
|
No. of Fatalities
|
Civilian Involvement
|
X-1 |
Bell Aircraft |
3
|
1946-51
|
157
|
Edwards AFB |
Investigate flight characteristics
at greater than sonic velocities. Structural, physiological phenomena within
transonic speed envelope |
First Mach 1+ flight; Maximum
altitude of 71,902 ft |
1
|
Defueling Explosion |
0
|
None |
X-1A |
Bell Aircraft |
1
|
1953-55
|
25
|
Edwards AFB |
Continue X-1 goals at higher speeds
and altitudes |
Obtained speed of Mach 2.44; Maximum
altitude of 90,440 ft |
1
|
Explosion during captive flight;
vehicle jettisoned |
0
|
None |
X-1B |
Bell Aircraft |
1
|
1954-58
|
27
|
Edwards AFB |
Exploratory aerodynamic heating
tests; experimental reaction control system |
First reaction controlled flight |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-1D |
Bell Aircraft |
1
|
1951
|
1
|
Edwards AFB |
Continue X-1 goals at higher speeds
and altitudes |
No major milestones |
1
|
Explosion during captive flight;
vehicle jettisoned |
0
|
None |
X-1E |
Bell Aircraft, Stanley Aircraft
(wings) |
1
|
1955-58
|
26
|
Edwards AFB |
High-speed wing performance |
Mach 2.24, altitude 73,458 ft;
first flight with ventral fins |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-2 |
Bell Aircraft |
2
|
1952-56
|
20
|
Edwards AFB |
Swept-wing performance; higher
speeds and altitude than X-1 |
New altitude record of 126,200
ft; new speed record of Mach 2.87 |
2
|
Gasket explosion destroys first
X-2; second aircraft lost to inertial coupling |
3
|
None |
X-3 |
Douglas Aircraft |
1
|
1954-56
|
20
|
Edwards AFB |
High speed aerodynamic phenomenon;
titanium construction; take off, land under its own power |
Led to understanding of inertia
coupling |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-4 |
Northrop Aircraft |
2
|
1950-53
|
82
|
Edwards AFB |
Test tailless, semi-tailless configuration
at transonic speeds |
Showed tailless craft not suited
for transonic flight |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-5 |
Bell Aircraft |
2
|
1952-55
|
133
|
Edwards AFB |
Investigate aerodynamics of variable-seep-wing
design |
Successful sweep-wing operation |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-6 |
Convair Division, General Dynamics |
1 shield-test aircraft (modified B-36H)
|
1955-57
|
47
|
Convair Testing Facility |
Test feasibility of nuclear propulsion |
Program terminated before prototypes
constructed |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-7A, X-7A-3, X-7B, X-Q5 (unmanned) |
Lockheed Missiles |
61
|
1951-60
|
130
|
New Mexico |
Test viability of ramjet engines
for anti-aircraft missiles; modified to testing of powerplants |
Obtained Mach 4.31, first air-breathing
full-scale research aircraft designed as Mach 3 testbed |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-8A, X-8B, X-8C, X-8D Aerobees
(unmanned) |
Aerojet Engineering |
108 (X-8 designation) 800+ (Aerobees)
|
1947-56
|
Unknown
|
White Sands, Holloman AFB |
Upper air research, parachute
recovery system |
Peak altitude of 121 miles |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-9 (unmanned) |
Bell Aircraft |
31
|
1949-53
|
28
|
Holloman AFB |
Test air-to-surface missiles;
guidance systems, etc. |
First chemical warhead test vehicle
to test supersonic clusterable dispersion |
9 unsuccessful flights
|
Servo system failures |
0
|
Not applicable |
X-10 (unmanned) |
North American Aviation |
13
|
1955-59
|
15
|
Edwards AFB |
Testbed for cruise missile components |
Established technology base for
remote control; first Mach 2-capable target drone |
3 unsuccessful flights
|
Communications disruption; miswiring;
autopilot malfunction |
0
|
Not applicable |
X-11 (unmanned) |
Convair Astronautics Division |
8
|
1956-58
|
8
|
Cape Canaveral |
Provide flight data for Atlas
missile |
First ICBM prototypes |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-12 (unmanned) |
Convair Astronautics Division |
5
|
1958
|
5
|
Cape Canaveral |
Test 1½-propulsion-staging
guidance system, nose reentry configuration |
First intercontinental range mission
of 6,325 miles |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-13 |
Ryan Aeronautical Company |
2
|
1955-57
|
Unknown
|
Edwards AFB |
Test pure-jet vertical takeoff
and landing |
First successful VTOL flight on
jet thrust alone |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-14, X-14A, X-14B |
Bell Aircraft |
1
|
1957-81
|
Unknown
|
Moffet Field |
Test VTOL technology |
First VTOL aircraft using jet
thrust diverter system for vertical lift |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-15, X-15A-2 |
North American Aviation |
3
|
1959-68
|
199
|
X-15 High Range (Wendover, UT,
to Edwards AFB) |
Explore problems of space and
atmospheric flight at very high speeds and altitudes |
First manned hypersonic flight
vehicle; altitude of 354,200 ft obtained; Mach 6.33 reached |
4
|
Mid-flight explosions (2); loss
of control (1); collapsed landing gear (1) |
1
|
Not applicable |
X-16 |
Bell Aircraft |
Canceled
|
None
|
None
|
None |
High-altitude, long-range reconnaissance
aircraft |
Not applicable |
Not applicable
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-17 (unmanned) |
Lockheed Missiles |
26
|
1955-57
|
26
|
Holloman AFB |
Explore reentry characteristics |
High Mach effects on reentry vehicles |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-18 |
Hiller Aircraft |
1
|
1959-61
|
20
|
Edwards AFB |
Explore large VTOL vehicles |
First tilt-wing usage for VTOL |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-19 |
Curtiss-Wright |
2
|
1964-65
|
50
|
Caldwell; NAFEC, NJ |
Test VTOL technology using radial
lift |
Dual-tandem tilt propeller use |
1
|
Equipment failure |
0
|
Not applicable |
X-20 |
Boeing |
Canceled
|
None
|
None
|
None |
Piloted orbital flight |
Provided heat materials testing |
Not applicable
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-21A |
Northrop Corporation |
2
|
1963-64
|
Unknown
|
Edwards AFB |
Test full-scale boundary control
on large aircraft |
Proved Laminar Flow Control viable |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-22A |
Bell Aerospace |
2
|
1966-84
|
501
|
Bell, Calspan Test Facilities |
Research dual-tandem-ducted propeller
configuration; research V/STOL handling using variable stability system
design |
Ducted fan viability, advancement
of VTOL technology |
1
|
hydraulic system failure |
0
|
None |
X-23A (unmanned) |
Martin Marietta |
4
|
1966-67
|
3
|
Vandenberg AFB/Pacific Ocean |
Test configurations, control systems,
and ablative materials for hypersonic reentry vehicles |
First maneuverable reentry vehicle |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-24A, X-24B |
Martin Marietta |
1
|
1969-75
|
64
|
Edwards AFB |
Research of aerodynamics, flight
characteristics of manned vehicle with FDL-7 configuration |
Verified theoretical advantages
of lifting body configuration for hypersonic transatmospheric aircraft |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-25, X-25A, X-25B |
Bensen Aircraft |
3
|
1968
|
|
Raleigh, NC |
Test discretionary descent vehicle
designs |
Insight on pilot training |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-26A, X-26B |
Schweizer Aircraft, Lockheed Missiles |
6
|
1967-88
|
Unknown
|
Vietnam |
Develop ultra-quiet surveillance
aircraft |
Use as training vehicle; contributions
to stealth designs |
3
|
Training exercises |
0
|
Not applicable |
X-27 |
Lockheed-California |
Canceled
|
None
|
None
|
None |
Advanced, lightweight fighter |
None |
Not applicable
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-28A |
George Pereira, Osprey Aircraft |
1
|
1971
|
Unknown
|
Philadelphia Naval Base, PA |
Explore usefulness of small, single-place
seaplane for civil police patrol in Southeast Asia |
Unique contribution as home-built
aircraft in X-Plane program |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-29A |
Grumman Aerospace |
2
|
1984-90
|
Unknown
|
Edwards AFB |
Test forward-swept wing design,
advanced composites, other aerodynamic advances |
First FSW aircraft to fly supersonically
in level flight |
0
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-30 |
None selected |
None
|
None
|
None
|
None |
Serve as testbed for sustained
hypersonic speeds within atmosphere or as space vehicles for orbital payload
delivery |
Not applicable |
Not applicable
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
X-31A |
Rockwell International, Deutsche
Aerospace |
2
|
1990-95
|
523
|
Edwards AFB |
Break "stall-barrier," examine
angles of attack |
180 degree turn post-stall maneuver |
1
|
Failure of the pitot ñ static
system: erroneous total pressure data |
0
|
None |
X-33 |
Lockheed-Martin Skunk Works |
None
|
None
|
None
|
None |
Develop reusable single-stage-to-orbit
transportation vehicle |
Not applicable |
Not applicable
|
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Not applicable |
Key to Acronyms:
AFB = Air Force Base
FDL-7 = Flight
Dynamics Laboratory-7 (a prototype test craft of the Air Force's Flight
Dynamics Laboratory, a predecessor to the X-24B).
FSW = forward swept wing
ICBM = intercontinental ballistic missile
V/STOL = vertical/short takeoff and landing
VTOL = vertical takeoff and landing |