Figure from the Apollo
14 Press Kit, showing the astronaut on the right
signalling that he is getting cooling via the BSLSS
connection from his buddy on the left. (More
detailed schematic below)
|
1. Summary
The BSLSS (described below) was a set of hoses and connectors
that allowed a crew to share cooling water in the event that one
of the PLSSs failed. By sharing cooling water with his
partner, the astronaut with the failed PLSS could operate his
Oxygen Purge System in low-flow and get about twice the useful
life available in the high-flow mode. The OPS/BSLSS
combination gave the two astronauts about 75 minutes to reach
safety of the LM cabin.
A BSLSS was first flown on Apollo 14. Interestingly, with
the exception of Charlie Duke, none of the Apollo 14 - 17
astronauts who participated in ALSJ mission reviews remembered
that the BSLSS was designed to share cooling water, rather than
oxygen.
Jack Schmitt, from a
conversation
during the Apollo 17 ALSJ mission review: "It rings a very
faint bell that we had something called a Buddy SLSS; and the
fact that neither of us remembers much about it shows how much
we felt we'd need it!"
Another reason was undoubtedly that fact that the BSLSS donning
and doffing procedures were simple. When asked during the
Apollo 16 ALSJ mission review if he and John had done much
training on "disconnects and reconnects in the field",
Charlie
answered:
"Not a lot. But we'd done
it enough. It was a simple procedure. We could
have done that with no
problem."
And, in response to a December 2008 question about any training
he and Al Shepard might have done for an emergency return to the
LM using the BSLSS, Ed Mitchell wrote:
"Frankly, we never trained on
that emergency at all. We knew we had it (meaning the
BSLSS) and looked at the equipment, but that was the extent of
it."
2. Background
The Apollo 11 and 12 crews stayed close to the LM.
During the Apollo 11 EVA, neither crewmember went more than 60
meters from the LM. On Apollo 12, the crew was prepared
to travel as much as a kilometer from the LM to reach the
Surveyor III spacecraft had they landed off target. In
the event of a sudden and complete failure of one of the
PLSSs, the Oxygen Purge System (OPS) mounted on top of the
failed PLSS could provide both CO2 purging and cooling
for about 39 minutes in the high-flow mode. The Apollo 12 site
is relatively level and the crew would have been able to run
back at a speed of roughly 3 km/hr. Depending on how far
they were from the LM, they would have been back in 20 minutes
or less, giving them at least 19 minutes - and an unused OPS -
for getting back in the cabin. (At the time Section 4.4 of Apollo 17
Final Lunar Surface Procedures was written, 13 minutes were
allocated for Emergency LM Ingress.)
Similarly, the Apollo 13 crew planned to land at Fra Mauro,
at the same location where Apollo 14 later landed.
During the second EVA, they intended to make a traverse to the
rim of Cone Crater, a trip that would take them about 1250
meters from the LM. Because of the need to make their
way around craters along the route, a more realistic travel
distance was about 1400 meters. At 3 km/hr, at the end
of a 1.4-km, 28-minute trip back to the LM, they would have
had roughly 11 minutes of time remaining on one of the OPSs
and could use the second OPS for ingress.
In the weeks before Apollo 12, NASA began to take a closer look
at the needs of the Apollo 16-20 crews, who would have the Lunar
Roving vehicle and would make drives of up to 8
kilometers. In the event that one of the two PLSSs failed
completely, the crew could be faced with a drive of up to an
hour back to the LM. Use of the two OPSs succesively in
high-flow would get them back to the LM with only about 18
minutes remaining on the second OPS. In principle, that
would have allowed an Emergency LM Ingress, but with an
uncomfortably thin margin.
At a 10 October 1969 meeting of the Manned Space Flight
Management Council, "Major Milestones were reached for extending
astronauts' staytime on the moon and increasing their mobility
for the Apollo 16 - 20 missions. Modification of the A7L
spacesuit incorporating improved waist mobility were authorized,
and letter contract authority for the portable life support
system/secondary life support system was approved."
Increased waist mobility would allow the astronauts to sit on
the Rover and would improve running speed. Increased
capacity of the PLSSs would allow 8-hour EVA. We have not
been able to locate details of an advanced Secondary Life
Support System (SSSS) that was under consideration.
However, in a 3 November 1969 letter to James McDivitt, then
Manager of the Apollo Spacecraft Program, "Christopher C. Kraft,
Jr., MSC Director of Flight Operations, suggested that an
in-house review re-evaluate the Apollo secondary life support
system, because of its complexity and cost of development, and,
at the same time re-examine the possibilities of an expanded
oxygen purge system using identical concepts." The Buddy
Secondary Life Supoort System was an effective, relatively
inexpensive result of the re-evaluation.
From a
conversation
with Dave Scott during the mission review conducted for the ALSJ
during 1992-3:
Scott - "Well, I think (the
BSLSS was) probably an evolution from the SCUBA (Self-Contained
Underwater
Breathing
Apparatus)
work
we did. As you probably know, everybody was trained in scuba.
We went to the Navy's Underwater Demolition School and got all
that training, with two tanks, not one tank. So we stayed down
a long time, which was a lot of fun. Another nice element of
what we were taught."
"In SCUBA, you are trained that, if you lose your mouthpiece
or oxygen, you breath on your buddy's oxygen. So I would say,
off the top of my head, that when we get into on-the-Moon
exercises, you think about the buddy system and you think
about breathing underwater, and you think, 'Gee, if my oxygen
goes out, I'll tap into my buddy's oxygen. Because that's
already demonstrated and that works out very well. That may
have been the evolution. I thought it was obviously a good
idea. Before we were assigned the Rover, we had the longer
duration, seven-hour PLSS, so we were going to be able to go
much further than 14 (who had a four-hour PLSS capability,
with margins), even if we only had a MET, which would mean
that the buddy system would be even more important. And we
practiced it, and I think it was a great idea."
The fact that, twenty years after Apollo, Dave mistakenly
thought the BLSS was used to share oxygen, rather than cooling
water, is irrelevant. The principle is the same.
3. BSLSS Description
Figure I-48 from Volume 1 of the Apollo 14 EMU Handbook
(Click on the image for a larger version)
From the
Apollo 14 EMU
Handbook, Vol. I:
2.9.2
Buddy
Secondary Life Support System
The BSLSS enables two EVA
crewmen to share the water cooling provided by one of their
PLSS's following loss of this capability in the other PLSS. The system (fig. 1-48) is made up of six principal components:
a. Two water hoses 8-1/2 feet long and 3/8 inch
inside diameter, to carry the coolant flow between the
good PLSS and the
other crewman;
b. A normal PLSS water
connector on one end of this double hose;
c. A flow-dividing
connector on the other end of this double hose consisting
of an ordinary PLSS water connector coupled with a receptacle to accept a
PLSS water connector;
d. A 4-1/2-foot restraint
tether with hooks for attachment to the PGA LM restraint
loops;
e. A thermal sheath the
length of the hoses with tether breakouts 2 feet from each
end;
f. A thermal pouch for
stowage of the assembly on the PLSS during EVA and in the
LM cabin during non-EVA periods.
During the Apollo 14 EVAs, the BSLSS bag was stowed on the
Modular Equipment Transporter (MET) and, during the Apollo 15-17
traverses, it was hung from the back of one of the Rover seats.
Detail
from AS15-85-11470,
showing the BSLSS bag hanging from the back of Jim
Irwin's Rover seat. (Click on the image for a
larger version.) |
4. BSLSS Donning and Activation
BSLSS pages from Charlie
Duke's flown EVA-1 Cuff Checklist.
Images courtesy Ron Shelton, South Carolina State Museum.
The procedures given in the Apollo 14, 15, and 17 cuff
checklists are nearly identical to these, differing only in
that the words "Good PLSS on RH side" in Item 2 on the
first of the two pages does not appear in the Apollo 14
version. Clearly, use of the BSLSS required that the
astronaut with the good PLSS be on his buddy's right.